Image Credit: Stephanie Fair / Facebook & Canva.
Article by Olivia Lupia, Tennessee Conservative News –
A former member of the 1990s pop group Wild Orchid will receive a $70,000 settlement from the Tennessee Highway Patrol (THP) after bloodwork proved she was sober at the time of her DUI arrest.
Former musician and reality TV star Stefanie Fair, 53, was pulled over in 2024 by Trooper Keith Valez for “failing to move over” when the trooper claimed her car “reeked of alcohol”. In the bodycam footage, Fair apologized for failing to yield but expressed confusion at the trooper’s statement that he smelled alcohol.
“On my life, I don’t drink alcohol,” Fair said, a claim she repeated several times as she underwent a field sobriety test. Valez’s notes from the arrest claimed she displayed clues of being intoxicated.
“When he started asking me about drinking, I instantly got this feeling in my stomach- this is bad,” Fair told media in a later interview. “When he said he could smell it, I knew it was corrupt. This is completely wrong.”
Fair was arrested and charged with DUI, but when her bloodwork came back two months later it showed no alcohol or drugs in her system. Video found by Fair’s attorney Ben Raybin also showed she was in an ice cream shop just an hour before being pulled over.

Roughly two years later, Fair is finally set to receive a settlement after filing suit against THP for wrongful arrest. A spokesperson for the attorney general’s office said the state board of claims has approved the $70,000 settlement and the payout should be made in the next few weeks.
As there is no recourse in Tennessee for sober drivers to recoup their costs if they are wrongly arrested, even after DUI charges are dropped, Raybin said the only option for those individuals is to sue.
“I think that the state has recognized that a lot of these arrests are just completely legally unsupportable and that if they went to a jury trial, a jury would find against them,” Raybin said of the settlement.
Court records show that lawsuits by sober drivers against the state are stacking up, with one trooper, James Zahn, accused of arresting nine sober drivers for DUI. Fair is also the second person to sue THP over wrongful arrest of sober drivers and settle.
Thomas Manis was arrested by THP troopers in 2023 for DUI, but his bloodwork came back clean. Manis then sued in federal court for unlawful seizure and false arrest, but THP denied the arrest was unlawful. The case was later dismissed, and the Tennessee Board of Claims confirmed Manis was awarded a $75,000 settlement.
THP is not the only agency in the state to settle sober driver suits.

The Rutherford County Sheriff’s Office settled a suit earlier this year over the case of David Dutton who was 76 at the time of his arrest in 2023. Dutton’s bloodwork showed he had no alcohol or drugs in his system, and bodycam footage of the incident showed Dutton explaining his health problems could impact his ability to properly perform the field sobriety test alongside a disability placard on his car.
Dutton received a $90,000 payout as part of his settlement from the suit. And court records indicate La Vergne police has also settled at least one sober driver lawsuit.
Data released by the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation (TBI) in January of this year showed 419 sober drivers were improperly arrested for DUI in Tennessee in 2024. THP troopers made 180 of those arrests, the most of any police agency in the state.
A change to the state’s implied consent law also took effect on January 1, 2026, which raised questions during the legislative process among citizens concerned with wrongful DUI charges by law enforcement. Under the new law, drivers who refuse to submit to a blood test while under investigation for suspected DUI risk having their license suspended for up to 18 months. Officers are also allowed to request saliva tests, and use “reasonable force” to obtain a blood sample.
Sources:
WSMV.
WVLT.
WSMV.
WSMV.
WSMV.
WSMV.


About the Author: Olivia Lupia is a political refugee from Colorado who now calls Tennessee home. A proud follower of Christ, she views all political happenings through a Biblical lens and aims to utilize her knowledge and experience to educate and equip others. Olivia is an outspoken conservative who has run for local office, managed campaigns, and been highly involved with state & local GOPs, state legislatures, and other grassroots organizations and movements. Olivia can be reached at olivia@tennesseeconservativenews.com.
