Note from The Tennessee Conservative: Editorial statements in this column are the sole opinion of the author; they do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the staff of this publication.
Submitted by Peter Maher –
Tennessee has been given an unusually revealing lesson in tax policy. Republican state Sen. Tom Hatcher of Maryville recently asked Gov. Bill Lee to suspend Tennessee’s 27.4-cent-per-gallon gasoline tax for 30 days in November. Hatcher’s reasoning goes directly to the economic reality facing working Tennesseans: “regular citizens need some help.” He is right to raise the issue. But Tennessee should ask a larger question, too: How did we get here?
One of Tennessee’s most celebrated Republican political figures, former Gov. Lamar Alexander, now describes his own administration’s strategy in remarkably plain language: “We’re going to double the gas tax.” Put those two moments beside each other. That history deserves scrutiny. A current Republican state senator from Maryville, the same Tennessee community where Lamar Alexander grew up, now argues that ordinary Tennesseans need temporary relief from the gasoline tax.
Decades earlier, Alexander dramatically increased the very tax Tennesseans continue paying every time they fill their tanks. The connection is hard to miss: two Republican politicians from Maryville are now on opposite sides of the same basic tax story. One fondly remembers increasing the gas tax as part of his governing record; the other says “regular Tennesseans need some help” and is asking for a temporary break from it.
Alexander’s journey from rural East Tennessee to some of the most powerful institutions in American public education and government is remarkable. Along the way, red-and-black plaid work shirts, work khakis and work boots became part of the political image he carefully curated for himself. He graduated from private Vanderbilt University in 1962 and earned his law degree from private New York University School of Law in New York City in 1965. An intriguing, though unconfirmed, part of Alexander’s New York story is that he apparently bought his first red-and-black plaid work shirts, work khakis and work boots in the cool 1960s beatnik neighborhoods around New York University. I have not yet been able to independently confirm.
What can be documented is what his plaid work shirt eventually meant politically. Alexander himself called it “the trademark of a winning, grass-roots campaign.” A trademark is branding, and branding is marketing. He would go on to become governor of our state, a United States senator, president of the University of Tennessee and, in 1991, U.S. secretary of education. Now that’s quite a career in both politics and philosophy.
Alexander spent decades seeking credibility in conservative Republican politics. Yet his voting record tells a more complicated story. Voteview found him more liberal than 93 percent of Senate Republicans during the 116th Congress. That tension between political image and governing record can be seen much earlier in his career. As governor, Alexander now openly describes his administration’s decision to “double the gas tax.” Alexander isn’t running away from that record. He sounds proud of it.
In a recent interview on Republican Tennessee state Sen. Bo Watson’s YouTube channel, Alexander discussed his administration’s strategy for attracting the Saturn automobile plant to Spring Hill and building roads to support it. Saturn Parkway now provides access between the plant and I-65. Alexander’s words are remarkably direct: “We got to fix the roads to get the Saturn plants here. So we’re going to have a huge road program and we’re going to double the (state) gas tax to pay for it….” Alexander incredibly made that statement in “How Lamar Alexander Became One of Tennessee’s Most Respected Leaders,” published on Watson’s YouTube channel.
Then Alexander went further. Describing the political work required to accomplish it, he asserted: “All the Republicans, by the way, voted for that at the time.” That’s Alexander’s characterization of what happened. But there is no need to take his word for the size of the gasoline-tax increase. Tennessee’s own public records document it.
The question isn’t whether two Middle Tennessee counties needed better roads to support the General Motors project. The question is why ordinary, working-class Tennesseans across 95 counties shouldered a dramatically higher gasoline tax as part of an economic-development strategy tied to a single automobile plant and surrounding transportation infrastructure in Middle Tennessee. And that raises another obvious question: Once the roads and infrastructure used to justify the tax increase had been built, why wasn’t the increase removed? A tax imposed to help finance a particular infrastructure program can become something very different when the projects are completed but the higher tax remains.
To be especially clear, Alexander didn’t just double our gas tax. The Tennessee Department of Transportation’s official gas-tax history gives us a chronology. Tennessee’s gasoline tax had been 7 cents per gallon. It increased to 9 cents in 1981. In 1985, it rose to 12 cents. Then Public Act 931 of 1986 established a 16-cent gasoline tax. Alexander was Tennessee’s governor from January 1979 until January 1987. So Alexander’s own description actually understates the math. Going from 7 cents to 16 cents means the gas tax didn’t merely double; it increased by about 129%. In other words, Tennessee’s gasoline tax more than doubled during the Alexander years. And today Alexander himself describes the policy in plain language: “we’re going to double the gas tax.” That deserves to be a big part of his legacy.
And it becomes even more relevant when a Republican state senator from Maryville is telling Tennessee’s governor in 2026 that motorists need relief from that tax. Hatcher requested that Lee suspend the current 27.4-cent gasoline tax for November. Explaining why, Hatcher said that Tennessee had provided help to farmers facing high fuel costs, but “regular citizens need some help” as well. If suspending the gasoline tax provides meaningful relief to ordinary Tennesseans when family budgets are strained, then the burden created by the gasoline tax deserves scrutiny when politicians increase it, too. We can’t discuss the relief provided by removing a tax without also discussing the burden created by imposing it.
Alexander built a political image around red-and-black plaid work shirts, work khakis and work boots, which he may have bought in the beatnik neighborhoods surrounding his private New York City law school. Again, I haven’t been able to independently confirm that part of the story. His own Senate campaign would later invoke his “conservative roots” and “common-sense, conservative Tennessee values.” Yet Alexander now openly recalls that, as governor, his administration pursued a successful plan to “double the gas tax.”
But who did Alexander think would bear a state gas tax like that? The question isn’t simply whether government needed roads or whether transportation infrastructure contributed to “economic development.” There is another question that matters, particularly to working-class Tennesseans: Who carries the greatest burden when state government raises money through taxes on basic consumption? For struggling Tennesseans, this isn’t a dumb question. Tennessee’s governors and General Assembly decide how the state raises its money. Working Tennesseans live with those choices every day. A gasoline tax doesn’t care whether someone must drive 10 miles or 75 miles just to earn a paycheck.
A Tennessean in Maryville working an hourly or modest-paying job may have little choice about buying gasoline. In much of Tennessee, getting to work requires driving. Trips to the grocery store, the farmers’ co-op, doctor’s office, school and childcare probably require a vehicle. For working Tennesseans living paycheck to paycheck, those consumption taxes come out of money that is also needed for everyday necessities. Tennessee’s struggling working families carry that burden. That’s who. That is worth asking when working Tennessee households confront gasoline taxes, sales taxes and other consumption taxes simply going about our everyday lives.
And it is especially worth asking when two Republican politicians from East Tennessee, separated by generations, illustrate two sides of the same tax. Alexander’s statement about the past is unmistakable: “We’re going to double the gas tax.” Hatcher’s argument in 2026 is equally revealing: “Regular citizens need some help.”
Tennessee’s gas-tax records tell us what happened during the Alexander administration: 7 cents became 9 cents in 1981, then 12 cents in 1985, then 16 cents under legislation enacted in 1986. Alexander’s own account makes clear that he regarded the tax increase as part of his administration’s road and economic-development strategy. Decades later, Tennessee motorists pay a 27.4-cent state gasoline tax, and a Republican state senator from Maryville is asking Tennessee’s Republican governor to suspend it for a month because ordinary citizens need relief. This is more than a coincidence. It puts a spotlight on the central question surrounding Tennessee’s tax structure: Who ultimately pays for the choices state government makes?
Today, Tennessee has the nation’s second-highest average combined state and local sales-tax rate and a state and local tax system that ITEP ranks as America’s third-most regressive. Alexander had opportunities that took him from rural Tennessee to private Vanderbilt University, private New York University School of Law, the Tennessee governor’s office, the U.S. Senate and the U.S. Department of Education. His documented path into political power ran through other people’s campaigns, congressional staff work, the White House, law and Republican campaign politics, not an urban Tennessee Title I classroom teaching position, a skilled-trades career, a Tennessee cattle farm or documented frontline military service. His tax record deserves to be examined with equal attention.
Tennessee has chosen which taxes to levy and which ones not to levy. Its political leadership has built a system that relies heavily on taxes working Tennesseans encounter in their everyday lives. That distinction matters. Look past the slogans and the reality becomes clear: Tennessee’s working class encounters that tax structure every day, at the cash register and at the gasoline pump.
In the end, Alexander’s red-and-black plaid work shirt, work khakis and work boots made for cute political marketing. But the clothes aren’t the legacy. His policies are. And when a Republican state senator from Maryville is asking the governor to temporarily remove Tennessee’s gasoline tax because “regular citizens need some help,” working Tennesseans are entitled to ask how the tax became such a substantial part of the price at the pump in the first place. They are also entitled to examine the political legacy of the governor who proudly remembers saying: “We’re going to double the gas tax.”
On Tennessee’s Gas Tax, All Roads Lead To Maryville (Op-Ed By Peter Maher)
On Tennessee’s Gas Tax, All Roads Lead To Maryville (Op-Ed By Peter Maher)
Image Credit: Canva.
Note from The Tennessee Conservative: Editorial statements in this column are the sole opinion of the author; they do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the staff of this publication.
Submitted by Peter Maher –
Tennessee has been given an unusually revealing lesson in tax policy. Republican state Sen. Tom Hatcher of Maryville recently asked Gov. Bill Lee to suspend Tennessee’s 27.4-cent-per-gallon gasoline tax for 30 days in November. Hatcher’s reasoning goes directly to the economic reality facing working Tennesseans: “regular citizens need some help.” He is right to raise the issue. But Tennessee should ask a larger question, too: How did we get here?
One of Tennessee’s most celebrated Republican political figures, former Gov. Lamar Alexander, now describes his own administration’s strategy in remarkably plain language: “We’re going to double the gas tax.” Put those two moments beside each other. That history deserves scrutiny. A current Republican state senator from Maryville, the same Tennessee community where Lamar Alexander grew up, now argues that ordinary Tennesseans need temporary relief from the gasoline tax.
Decades earlier, Alexander dramatically increased the very tax Tennesseans continue paying every time they fill their tanks. The connection is hard to miss: two Republican politicians from Maryville are now on opposite sides of the same basic tax story. One fondly remembers increasing the gas tax as part of his governing record; the other says “regular Tennesseans need some help” and is asking for a temporary break from it.
Alexander’s journey from rural East Tennessee to some of the most powerful institutions in American public education and government is remarkable. Along the way, red-and-black plaid work shirts, work khakis and work boots became part of the political image he carefully curated for himself. He graduated from private Vanderbilt University in 1962 and earned his law degree from private New York University School of Law in New York City in 1965. An intriguing, though unconfirmed, part of Alexander’s New York story is that he apparently bought his first red-and-black plaid work shirts, work khakis and work boots in the cool 1960s beatnik neighborhoods around New York University. I have not yet been able to independently confirm.
What can be documented is what his plaid work shirt eventually meant politically. Alexander himself called it “the trademark of a winning, grass-roots campaign.” A trademark is branding, and branding is marketing. He would go on to become governor of our state, a United States senator, president of the University of Tennessee and, in 1991, U.S. secretary of education. Now that’s quite a career in both politics and philosophy.
Alexander spent decades seeking credibility in conservative Republican politics. Yet his voting record tells a more complicated story. Voteview found him more liberal than 93 percent of Senate Republicans during the 116th Congress. That tension between political image and governing record can be seen much earlier in his career. As governor, Alexander now openly describes his administration’s decision to “double the gas tax.” Alexander isn’t running away from that record. He sounds proud of it.
In a recent interview on Republican Tennessee state Sen. Bo Watson’s YouTube channel, Alexander discussed his administration’s strategy for attracting the Saturn automobile plant to Spring Hill and building roads to support it. Saturn Parkway now provides access between the plant and I-65. Alexander’s words are remarkably direct: “We got to fix the roads to get the Saturn plants here. So we’re going to have a huge road program and we’re going to double the (state) gas tax to pay for it….” Alexander incredibly made that statement in “How Lamar Alexander Became One of Tennessee’s Most Respected Leaders,” published on Watson’s YouTube channel.
Then Alexander went further. Describing the political work required to accomplish it, he asserted: “All the Republicans, by the way, voted for that at the time.” That’s Alexander’s characterization of what happened. But there is no need to take his word for the size of the gasoline-tax increase. Tennessee’s own public records document it.
The question isn’t whether two Middle Tennessee counties needed better roads to support the General Motors project. The question is why ordinary, working-class Tennesseans across 95 counties shouldered a dramatically higher gasoline tax as part of an economic-development strategy tied to a single automobile plant and surrounding transportation infrastructure in Middle Tennessee. And that raises another obvious question: Once the roads and infrastructure used to justify the tax increase had been built, why wasn’t the increase removed? A tax imposed to help finance a particular infrastructure program can become something very different when the projects are completed but the higher tax remains.
To be especially clear, Alexander didn’t just double our gas tax. The Tennessee Department of Transportation’s official gas-tax history gives us a chronology. Tennessee’s gasoline tax had been 7 cents per gallon. It increased to 9 cents in 1981. In 1985, it rose to 12 cents. Then Public Act 931 of 1986 established a 16-cent gasoline tax. Alexander was Tennessee’s governor from January 1979 until January 1987. So Alexander’s own description actually understates the math. Going from 7 cents to 16 cents means the gas tax didn’t merely double; it increased by about 129%. In other words, Tennessee’s gasoline tax more than doubled during the Alexander years. And today Alexander himself describes the policy in plain language: “we’re going to double the gas tax.” That deserves to be a big part of his legacy.
And it becomes even more relevant when a Republican state senator from Maryville is telling Tennessee’s governor in 2026 that motorists need relief from that tax. Hatcher requested that Lee suspend the current 27.4-cent gasoline tax for November. Explaining why, Hatcher said that Tennessee had provided help to farmers facing high fuel costs, but “regular citizens need some help” as well. If suspending the gasoline tax provides meaningful relief to ordinary Tennesseans when family budgets are strained, then the burden created by the gasoline tax deserves scrutiny when politicians increase it, too. We can’t discuss the relief provided by removing a tax without also discussing the burden created by imposing it.
Alexander built a political image around red-and-black plaid work shirts, work khakis and work boots, which he may have bought in the beatnik neighborhoods surrounding his private New York City law school. Again, I haven’t been able to independently confirm that part of the story. His own Senate campaign would later invoke his “conservative roots” and “common-sense, conservative Tennessee values.” Yet Alexander now openly recalls that, as governor, his administration pursued a successful plan to “double the gas tax.”
But who did Alexander think would bear a state gas tax like that? The question isn’t simply whether government needed roads or whether transportation infrastructure contributed to “economic development.” There is another question that matters, particularly to working-class Tennesseans: Who carries the greatest burden when state government raises money through taxes on basic consumption? For struggling Tennesseans, this isn’t a dumb question. Tennessee’s governors and General Assembly decide how the state raises its money. Working Tennesseans live with those choices every day. A gasoline tax doesn’t care whether someone must drive 10 miles or 75 miles just to earn a paycheck.
A Tennessean in Maryville working an hourly or modest-paying job may have little choice about buying gasoline. In much of Tennessee, getting to work requires driving. Trips to the grocery store, the farmers’ co-op, doctor’s office, school and childcare probably require a vehicle. For working Tennesseans living paycheck to paycheck, those consumption taxes come out of money that is also needed for everyday necessities. Tennessee’s struggling working families carry that burden. That’s who. That is worth asking when working Tennessee households confront gasoline taxes, sales taxes and other consumption taxes simply going about our everyday lives.
And it is especially worth asking when two Republican politicians from East Tennessee, separated by generations, illustrate two sides of the same tax. Alexander’s statement about the past is unmistakable: “We’re going to double the gas tax.” Hatcher’s argument in 2026 is equally revealing: “Regular citizens need some help.”
Tennessee’s gas-tax records tell us what happened during the Alexander administration: 7 cents became 9 cents in 1981, then 12 cents in 1985, then 16 cents under legislation enacted in 1986. Alexander’s own account makes clear that he regarded the tax increase as part of his administration’s road and economic-development strategy. Decades later, Tennessee motorists pay a 27.4-cent state gasoline tax, and a Republican state senator from Maryville is asking Tennessee’s Republican governor to suspend it for a month because ordinary citizens need relief. This is more than a coincidence. It puts a spotlight on the central question surrounding Tennessee’s tax structure: Who ultimately pays for the choices state government makes?
Today, Tennessee has the nation’s second-highest average combined state and local sales-tax rate and a state and local tax system that ITEP ranks as America’s third-most regressive. Alexander had opportunities that took him from rural Tennessee to private Vanderbilt University, private New York University School of Law, the Tennessee governor’s office, the U.S. Senate and the U.S. Department of Education. His documented path into political power ran through other people’s campaigns, congressional staff work, the White House, law and Republican campaign politics, not an urban Tennessee Title I classroom teaching position, a skilled-trades career, a Tennessee cattle farm or documented frontline military service. His tax record deserves to be examined with equal attention.
Tennessee has chosen which taxes to levy and which ones not to levy. Its political leadership has built a system that relies heavily on taxes working Tennesseans encounter in their everyday lives. That distinction matters. Look past the slogans and the reality becomes clear: Tennessee’s working class encounters that tax structure every day, at the cash register and at the gasoline pump.
In the end, Alexander’s red-and-black plaid work shirt, work khakis and work boots made for cute political marketing. But the clothes aren’t the legacy. His policies are. And when a Republican state senator from Maryville is asking the governor to temporarily remove Tennessee’s gasoline tax because “regular citizens need some help,” working Tennesseans are entitled to ask how the tax became such a substantial part of the price at the pump in the first place. They are also entitled to examine the political legacy of the governor who proudly remembers saying: “We’re going to double the gas tax.”