Hamilton County School Board Reaffirms 10 Commandment Display During Contentious Meeting

Hamilton County School Board Reaffirms 10 Commandment Display During Contentious Meeting

Hamilton County School Board Reaffirms 10 Commandment Display During Contentious Meeting

Image Credit: Hamilton County Schools / YouTube.

Article by Olivia Lupia, Tennessee Conservative News –

Last week’s Hamilton County School Board meeting grew heated as the body retook a vote on requiring the display of the Ten Commandments alongside other foundational documents in local schools when some members renewed arguments that the display forces Christianity on students and opens the district up to lawsuits and one was threatened with removal. 

The board previously voted 6-4 along party lines to approve the display of the Ten Commandments as part of an exhibit of several historical documents including sections of the U.S. Declaration of Independence and Constitution. But some members made a push to rescind the decision which sparked intense debate amongst the body.

Democrat member Ben Connor introduced a resolution to reverse the policy after claiming he was unable to see the display poster that was being considered until the morning of the vote, arguing he did not have ample time to obtain feedback from his constituents. 

Connor later claimed during the Nov. 12 meeting when his motion was being considered that 89% of emails he received were in opposition to the display and he was asking the board to “correct our mistake” so the district did not end up in “an incredibly costly frivolous lawsuit.”

Other members rallied in support of the display, including Gary Kuehn who said he had spoken with several pastors about the issue, sharing some comments that expressed their support for showcasing the Ten Commandments as part of “the development of American law, government, and culture.”

“Anyone who does an honest historical study of America’s founding will recognize that the Bible, and particularly the moral principles reflected in the 10 Commandments, had a significant influence on the thinking and institutions of early America. This does not mean that the founders all agreed on theology or that America was established as a theocracy. It does mean Biblical worldview was an important part of that intellectual, cultural, and environmental development in which our nation’s founding took place,” Kuehn relayed.

He added, “We are not trying to sway anybody to a certain faith or religion. We are only stating by posting this with the preamble and the constitution that the Ten Commandments affected our country’s 250 years of evolution…And that is why I will continue to vote to keep the Ten Commandments.”

Felice Hadden also stood by the board’s original vote, rebutting Connor’s claim about the number of opposition emails received. “Sometimes a vote goes our way, and sometimes it doesn’t,” she said. “Saying 89% of the emails are against this does not necessarily mean 89% of people are against it. I think there are people that are very unhappy that it passed and a lot of them, through a coordinated effort, are emailing. It doesn’t mean there aren’t many other people across the district who are happy with the decision.”

During the public comment section, Tennessee Stands Executive Director Anne Lowery also offered an argument in favor of the displays. “The phrase ‘separation of church and state” is treated by many as a constitutional command that religion must be scrubbed from public schools. It is not,” she stated.  

Ultimately, the board voted 7-4 along party lines to uphold their original decision to require the displays. The controversy then escalated as board members debated a different resolution that further declared the importance and rationale of including the Ten Commandments in the displays and reiterated how they would be presented. 

Jackie Thomas, who had voted to reverse the original decision, was reprimanded several times by Chairwoman Jodi Schaffer for “speaking out of turn” and interrupting while the members were receiving clarification about what they were voting upon. 

After issuing a second warning as Thomas continued to yell over the top of her, Schaffer declared Thomas was to be removed from the room, to which Thomas retorted, “You can’t remove me. You didn’t elect me. You can’t remove me because I asked for a question of clarification. You can do that gavel all you want; you haven’t been in order. Girl, please.”

The board’s attorney advised that though Thomas could absolutely be ruled out of order, she should be allowed to remain, stating her constituents would not be properly represented in the upcoming vote if she were removed from the room.

After further antagonistic statements and questions from Thomas, the board voted 7-4 in favor of the second resolution which will help the document displays proceed and bring a conclusion to a lengthy debate and quarrelsome meeting.

Sources:

Tennessee Conservative News.

Chattanoogan.

Tennessee Conservative News.

YouTube.

YouTube.

About the Author: Olivia Lupia is a political refugee from Colorado who now calls Tennessee home. A proud follower of Christ, she views all political happenings through a Biblical lens and aims to utilize her knowledge and experience to educate and equip others. Olivia is an outspoken conservative who has run for local office, managed campaigns, and been highly involved with state & local GOPs, state legislatures, and other grassroots organizations and movements. Olivia can be reached at olivia@tennesseeconservativenews.com.

Share this:

Leave a Reply

Stay Informed. Stay Ahead.

Before you go, don’t miss the headlines that matter—plus sharp opinions and a touch of humor, delivered to your inbox.

Subscribe now and never miss a beat.

Please prove you are human by selecting the star: